This post may contain affiliate links. Click here to see what that means.
“There is no food neutral; there is no food Switzerland—every single thing you put in your mouth is either making you more healthy or less healthy.” ~ Melissa Hartwig
Paleo Cupcakes, Cookies and Pies, Oh My!
Treats are a point of controversy in the paleo community. Some people point out that our ancestors never baked and had limited access to sugar, natural or otherwise. Others say that if paleo is designed to be a diet for life, we need it to be sustainable in modern life, and some days we just want a cookie. So, who is right? In the autoimmune community, this is an even more important question. We aren’t following paleo to simply optimize good health; we’re trying to reverse autoimmune disease, which is infinitely harder. The truth is, our bodies behave very differently than those without autoimmune disease, and sugar can have a bigger impact on our system than the general population. So, let’s look at all aspects of this question.
According to SugarScience.org, Americans consume an average of 66 pounds of added sugar per year. This isn’t the sugar naturally contained in fruits and vegetables. This is sugar added to packaged foods. Since most people on a paleo diet avoid packaged foods, we’re thankfully making healthier choices. However, we still need to be mindful of how much sugar (natural or otherwise) we choose to add to the paleo foods we do eat. We also need to watch out for the growing market of paleo packaged treats.
What Is Sugar?
Sugar is a carbohydrate found naturally in most plants. There are many ways human beings have found to extract and isolate it over the years, but what is sugar at its basic level? It’s made up of two molecules: glucose and fructose. When you combine them, it’s called sucrose. Glucose is a natural energy source for our bodies, and it’s one of the reasons human beings naturally crave sweet things. In ancestral times, it led us to want to eat the fruits and vegetables that provided us with this energy. The body can use glucose immediately, or it can store it in our muscles and liver as glycogen for later use. Insulin regulates what gets used vs. what gets stored. Fructose cannot be used immediately. It needs to be converted into glucose by the liver, and when we consume too much, it gets converted into fat. Sucrose is the combination of these two things, so it has an extra step in the digestion process – it first needs to be separated into glucose and fructose, and then it is used or stored accordingly.
There are over 60 different names for sugars on conventional packaged food labels. Here are the less refined sugars that you might see in paleo dessert recipes:
- Dried fruit
- Date sugar
- Raw honey
- Pure maple syrup
- Maple sugar
- Coconut/Palm sugar
- Sucanat/Evaporated cane juice
Some of these start out as sucrose, but after digestion they all break down to pretty much 50% glucose and 50% fructose, which ironically is the same ratio as refined white sugar. So why are these considered potentially paleo? On the plus side, they don’t come from GMO crops, they aren’t heavily refined, and they contain some trace vitamins and minerals. But let’s be honest – they aren’t health foods. The body will still identify these as sugar and react accordingly.
Sugar’s Impact on the Body
Since glucose is a natural energy source for our bodies, human beings are designed to eat a certain amount of sugar in the form of fruits and vegetables. They’re good for our health. The problem comes when we eat too much. We can do this by bingeing on fruit or desserts. When we consume more sugar than our body needs:
- Inflammation rises, which can exacerbate autoimmune symptoms.
- Blood sugar goes out of balance, which also affects autoimmune expression.
- Insulin resistance develops, which can lead to obesity, diabetes, heart disease and even cancer.
- Free radicals increase, causing oxidative stress bodywide.
- The liver becomes overworked, which can lead to fatty liver disease.
- Microbial balance shifts, leading to small intestine bacterial overgrowth and gut dysbiosis.
What the Paleo Health Leaders Say
“Blood sugar fluctuations, whether someone misses a meal or someone eats too much, actually trigger the autoimmune inflammatory pathway. That’s why it’s important to stabilize your blood sugar levels, because it can determine if you progress or go into remission.”
“Sugar is sugar and will feed the wrong bacteria in the gut. I recommend limiting sugars, which is why I prefer non-starchy vegetables and limiting fruit. If a person is very lean, the fruits may be better tolerated. If overweight or obese, I recommend limiting to one serving or less per day. I discourage the use of fructose based sweeteners (agave, maple syrup, coconut sugar, honey etc.) as they increase the risk of dysbiosis, fatty liver, metabolic syndrome, glucose intolerance, and diabetes. I recommend limiting sugar intake, to 1 teaspoon or less per day. Better to wean away from the sweet taste preference that we all have.”
“Naturally sweet whole foods, such as fruits, berries, beets, carrots, and sweet potatoes, most definitely have a place on an autoimmune protocol diet. They diversify the diet, providing beneficial fiber and nutrition; and the natural sugars they contain are beneficial to glycemic regulation and metabolism. However, ‘the dose makes the poison.’ Generally speaking, added sugar is almost always harmful.
Sugar is especially likely to be harmful in autoimmune disorders, because “disease begins in the gut” as Hippocrates said. Autoimmunity is commonly caused by bacterial infections or overgrowth in the small intestine, in which partially digested food compounds are incorporated into bacterial cell walls and then the immune system, reacting to the bacteria, forms antibodies that also recognize food compounds, some of which might cross-react with human counterparts.
So added sugar should generally be avoided. If sweeteners are used, then they should be limited to a tablespoon per day of raw honey (which has antimicrobial compounds) or of dextrose powder (which lacks fructose and is more readily absorbed). When eating food products with added sugar, limit the sweetness; for instance, chocolate should be 85% cocoa or higher.”
“I advocate a return to natural sources of sweetness, mainly fruit and even vegetables. When fruit becomes your dessert, your taste buds will quickly adapt, and it won’t be long before fruit tastes like a decadent treat even though you are consuming a food rich in antioxidants, vitamins and minerals.
However, we are human. We still want to celebrate birthdays and job promotions with food. The point of the Paleo Approach is not to deprive you of the joys of food or the celebrations of life, but to get you healthy. If you who want to try your hand at some baking, [understand] that this should be reserved for special occasions.”
While there are some nuanced differences in the answers above, all agree that sugar impacts autoimmune expression, and even natural sweeteners should be limited. The goal is to wean ourselves away from our sweet tooth. Once we do that, even vegetables can begin to taste sweet.
5 Tips for Healthy Dessert Choices
- Choose fresh fruit with optional coconut whipped cream. Berries are among the most nutrient-dense fruit choices, containing large amounts of antioxidants. They are also low on the glycemic index, meaning they have a minimal impact on blood sugar.
- Baked fruit increases the sweetness without increasing the sugar content. It does this by evaporating some of the water fresh fruit contains. Cook it with a healthy fat, sprinkle a little cinnamon or ginger on top, and enjoy a warm dessert on a cold, winter day.
- Are you an abstainer or a moderator? When it comes to sweet desserts like cake, cookies and ice cream, for many people, one taste makes them want more and more. In that case, the best way to wean yourself away from your sweet tooth is to avoid these recipes altogether. However, if you’re someone who is able stop at one cookie and feeling forbidden makes you rebel, then keeping a small stash of paleo desserts in the freezer might be the right choice for you.
- If you decide to make a paleo treat, ideally look for recipes that have a maximum of 1 tablespoon added sugar per serving. There are literally thousands of paleo dessert recipes on the internet now, and they vary widely in the amount of sweetener added. People seem to think that as long as it’s an unrefined sugar, the amount doesn’t matter. I’ve seen paleo cupcake recipes with 2 cups of sugar added for 1 dozen muffins, vs. cupcakes made with no added sugar at all. Start choosing the low-sugar recipes and let your taste buds adapt. If you have seen a high-sugar paleo dessert you really want to try, save it for a once-per-year special occasion like your birthday. Over time, you’ll likely find your birthday cravings start to change. Mine have!
- Always eat your dessert with a meal, to moderate the blood sugar effect. When we eat sugar by itself, it causes an immediate blood sugar spike, and as Dr. Kharrazian says above, that can lead to autoimmune flares. When we eat it alongside a meal with protein, fat and fiber, that moderates the blood sugar response. If you have a little apple cider vinegar in a small glass of water after your meal, that helps moderate blood sugar as well.
I’ve written a series of articles to guide you through the autoimmune protocol, step by step. It includes FAQ, mistakes to avoid, book reviews, and more. Click here to see the whole list.
Did you know that I write a regular column for Paleo Magazine, called Autoimmune Answers? That’s where a version of this article first appeared. I love this magazine – they are the only print publication for the paleo community, and the quality of both the writing and photography is top-notch. Psssst: a copy on the coffee table at home, or the break room at work, is a subtle way to spread the good paleo word. They’re sold at many Whole Foods and Barnes & Noble stores, or you can subscribe online.
Photo credit: Roxy M Jones via Pixabay (public domain).